This page in plain text
ChatGPT or Claude?
We pay for both and use both every week. Claude does most of our work. ChatGPT is for quick questions, images and voice, and it is where we go for a second opinion.
What each one is
- Claude. Best for: writing, long documents, following a detailed brief. Anthropic’s assistant. We reach for it when the writing matters, when the document is long, or when the brief has many parts that all have to be followed. It can also build a small working page or document beside the chat while you watch.
- ChatGPT. Best for: everyday questions, images, talking out loud. OpenAI’s assistant, and the one most people try first. It is a good all-rounder: it writes, searches the web, reads files you give it, makes images and holds a spoken conversation. If you only try one tool, this is a fair first choice.
Our answer
We use both. Claude does most of our work, including nearly all of our development. ChatGPT is for quick questions, images and voice, and it is our second opinion: when Claude gets stuck on a problem, we put the same problem to ChatGPT.
If you can pay for only one, we would choose Claude.
Neither one annoys us. What matters more than the choice is staying with it: the more you use these tools, the better you get at them, and the better your own system for working with them becomes.
This is what we do ourselves, not a score. We have not run the two side by side on a set of tests.
Pick Claude if
- The writing has to sound right, or the document is long.
- Your brief has many parts that all have to be followed.
- You build things. Nearly all of our development is done with it.
Pick ChatGPT if
- Most of what you ask is a quick question.
- You want images made in the same conversation.
- You would rather talk than type.
The fair test is your own task
- Write one brief. Take a real job from this week. Write the brief once, with the reader, the facts and the shape you want.
- Give it to both. The same words, the same files, on the same day. Change nothing between them.
- Keep the one you would use. Not the longer answer or the more polished one. The one you would send without rewriting.
The jobs we list each one for
- Claude: Write faster and still sound like yourself, Turn a long document into a short one, Plan a project from a rough idea, Turn meeting notes into actions, Learn a subject you keep putting off, Get ready for a job interview.
- ChatGPT: Write faster and still sound like yourself, Research a question and see the sources, Make sense of a spreadsheet, Plan a project from a rough idea, Make an image for a post or a deck, Get ready for a job interview.
Other comparisons: Claude Code or Codex?, The Claude API or the OpenAI API? Or see all the tools we use.
Ask Another AI Guy
I'm just Another AI Guy.
You're chatting with our fast model. Create a free account for the more thorough one, and more messages.